com.mebigfatguy.fbcontrib.detect

Class SuspiciousComparatorReturnValues

java.lang.Object

edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.BetterVisitor

edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.PreorderVisitor

edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.AnnotationVisitor

edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.DismantleBytecode

edu.umd.cs.findbugs.BytecodeScanningDetector

com.mebigfatguy.fbcontrib.detect.SuspiciousComparatorReturnValues

All Implemented Interfaces:

edu.umd.cs.findbugs.Detector, edu.umd.cs.findbugs.Priorities, edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.Constants2, org.apache.bcel.classfile.Visitor, org.apache.bcel.Constants

@OpcodeStack.CustomUserValue
public class SuspiciousComparatorReturnValues
extends edu.umd.cs.findbugs.BytecodeScanningDetector

looks for class that implement Comparator or Comparable, and whose compare or compareTo methods return constant values only, but that don't represent the three possible choice (a negative number, 0, and a positive number).

Field Summary

Fields

Modifier and Type	Field and Description
private edu.umd.cs.findbugs.BugReporter	bugReporter
private static java.util.List<CompareSpec>	compareClasses
private int	furthestBranchTarget
private MethodInfo	methodInfo
private java.lang.Integer	sawConstant
private boolean	seenNegative
private boolean	seenPositive
private boolean	seenUnconditionalNonZero
private boolean	seenZero
private edu.umd.cs.findbugs.OpcodeStack	stack

Fields inherited from class edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.DismantleBytecode

codeBytes, lineNumberTable, M_BR, M_CP, M_INT, M_PAD, M_R, M_UINT

Fields inherited from interface edu.umd.cs.findbugs.Priorities

EXP_PRIORITY, HIGH_PRIORITY, IGNORE_PRIORITY, LOW_PRIORITY, NORMAL_PRIORITY

Fields inherited from interface org.apache.bcel.Constants

AALOAD, AASTORE, ACC_ABSTRACT, ACC_ANNOTATION, ACC_BRIDGE, ACC_ENUM, ACC_FINAL, ACC_INTERFACE, ACC_NATIVE, ACC_PRIVATE, ACC_PROTECTED, ACC_PUBLIC, ACC_STATIC, ACC_STRICT, ACC_SUPER, ACC_SYNCHRONIZED, ACC_SYNTHETIC, ACC_SYPER, ACC_TRANSIENT, ACC_VARARGS, ACC_VOLATILE, ACCESS_NAMES, ACONST_NULL, ALOAD, ALOAD_0, ALOAD_1, ALOAD_2, ALOAD_3, ANEWARRAY, ANEWARRAY_QUICK, APPEND_FRAME, APPEND_FRAME_MAX, ARETURN, ARRAYLENGTH, ASTORE, ASTORE_0, ASTORE_1, ASTORE_2, ASTORE_3, ATHROW, ATTR_ANNOTATION_DEFAULT, ATTR_CODE, ATTR_CONSTANT_VALUE, ATTR_DEPRECATED, ATTR_ENCLOSING_METHOD, ATTR_EXCEPTIONS, ATTR_INNER_CLASSES, ATTR_LINE_NUMBER_TABLE, ATTR_LOCAL_VARIABLE_TABLE, ATTR_LOCAL_VARIABLE_TYPE_TABLE, ATTR_PMG, ATTR_RUNTIME_VISIBLE_ANNOTATIONS, ATTR_RUNTIME_VISIBLE_PARAMETER_ANNOTATIONS, ATTR_RUNTIMEIN_VISIBLE_ANNOTATIONS, ATTR_RUNTIMEIN_VISIBLE_PARAMETER_ANNOTATIONS, ATTR_SIGNATURE, ATTR_SOURCE_FILE, ATTR_STACK_MAP, ATTR_STACK_MAP_TABLE, ATTR_SYNTHETIC, ATTR_UNKNOWN, ATTRIBUTE_NAMES, BALOAD, BASTORE, BIPUSH, BREAKPOINT, CALOAD, CASTORE, CHECKCAST, CHECKCAST_QUICK, CHOP_FRAME, CHOP_FRAME_MAX, CLASS_TYPE_NAMES, CONSTANT_Class, CONSTANT_Double, CONSTANT_Fieldref, CONSTANT_Float, CONSTANT_Integer, CONSTANT_InterfaceMethodref, CONSTANT_InvokeDynamic, CONSTANT_Long, CONSTANT_MethodHandle, CONSTANT_Methodref, CONSTANT_MethodType, CONSTANT_NameAndType, CONSTANT_NAMES, CONSTANT_String, CONSTANT_Utf8, CONSTRUCTOR_NAME, CONSUME_STACK, D2F, D2I, D2L, DADD, DALOAD, DASTORE, DCMPG, DCMPL, DCONST_0, DCONST_1, DDIV, DLOAD, DLOAD_0, DLOAD_1, DLOAD_2, DLOAD_3, DMUL, DNEG, DREM, DRETURN, DSTORE, DSTORE_0, DSTORE_1, DSTORE_2, DSTORE_3, DSUB, DUP, DUP_X1, DUP_X2, DUP2, DUP2_X1, DUP2_X2, F2D, F2I, F2L, FADD, FALOAD, FASTORE, FCMPG, FCMPL, FCONST_0, FCONST_1, FCONST_2, FDIV, FLOAD, FLOAD_0, FLOAD_1, FLOAD_2, FLOAD_3, FMUL, FNEG, FREM, FRETURN, FSTORE, FSTORE_0, FSTORE_1, FSTORE_2, FSTORE_3, FSUB, FULL_FRAME, GETFIELD, GETFIELD_QUICK, GETFIELD_QUICK_W, GETFIELD2_QUICK, GETSTATIC, GETSTATIC_QUICK, GETSTATIC2_QUICK, GOTO, GOTO_W, I2B, I2C, I2D, I2F, I2L, I2S, IADD, IALOAD, IAND, IASTORE, ICONST_0, ICONST_1, ICONST_2, ICONST_3, ICONST_4, ICONST_5, ICONST_M1, IDIV, IF_ACMPEQ, IF_ACMPNE, IF_ICMPEQ, IF_ICMPGE, IF_ICMPGT, IF_ICMPLE, IF_ICMPLT, IF_ICMPNE, IFEQ, IFGE, IFGT, IFLE, IFLT, IFNE, IFNONNULL, IFNULL, IINC, ILLEGAL_OPCODE, ILLEGAL_TYPE, ILOAD, ILOAD_0, ILOAD_1, ILOAD_2, ILOAD_3, IMPDEP1, IMPDEP2, IMUL, INEG, INSTANCEOF, INSTANCEOF_QUICK, INT2BYTE, INT2CHAR, INT2SHORT, INTERFACES_IMPLEMENTED_BY_ARRAYS, INVOKEDYNAMIC, INVOKEINTERFACE, INVOKEINTERFACE_QUICK, INVOKENONVIRTUAL, INVOKENONVIRTUAL_QUICK, INVOKESPECIAL, INVOKESTATIC, INVOKESTATIC_QUICK, INVOKESUPER_QUICK, INVOKEVIRTUAL, INVOKEVIRTUAL_QUICK, INVOKEVIRTUAL_QUICK_W, INVOKEVIRTUALOBJECT_QUICK, IOR, IREM, IRETURN, ISHL, ISHR, ISTORE, ISTORE_0, ISTORE_1, ISTORE_2, ISTORE_3, ISUB, ITEM_Bogus, ITEM_Double, ITEM_Float, ITEM_InitObject, ITEM_Integer, ITEM_Long, ITEM_NAMES, ITEM_NewObject, ITEM_Null, ITEM_Object, IUSHR, IXOR, JSR, JSR_W, KNOWN_ATTRIBUTES, L2D, L2F, L2I, LADD, LALOAD, LAND, LASTORE, LCMP, LCONST_0, LCONST_1, LDC, LDC_QUICK, LDC_W, LDC_W_QUICK, LDC2_W, LDC2_W_QUICK, LDIV, LLOAD, LLOAD_0, LLOAD_1, LLOAD_2, LLOAD_3, LMUL, LNEG, LOOKUPSWITCH, LOR, LREM, LRETURN, LSHL, LSHR, LSTORE, LSTORE_0, LSTORE_1, LSTORE_2, LSTORE_3, LSUB, LUSHR, LXOR, MAJOR, MAJOR_1_1, MAJOR_1_2, MAJOR_1_3, MAJOR_1_4, MAJOR_1_5, MAJOR_1_6, MAJOR_1_7, MAJOR_1_8, MAX_ACC_FLAG, MAX_BYTE, MAX_CODE_SIZE, MAX_CP_ENTRIES, MAX_SHORT, MINOR, MINOR_1_1, MINOR_1_2, MINOR_1_3, MINOR_1_4, MINOR_1_5, MINOR_1_6, MINOR_1_7, MINOR_1_8, MONITORENTER, MONITOREXIT, MULTIANEWARRAY, MULTIANEWARRAY_QUICK, NEW, NEW_QUICK, NEWARRAY, NO_OF_OPERANDS, NOP, OPCODE_NAMES, POP, POP2, PRODUCE_STACK, PUSH, PUTFIELD, PUTFIELD_QUICK, PUTFIELD_QUICK_W, PUTFIELD2_QUICK, PUTSTATIC, PUTSTATIC_QUICK, PUTSTATIC2_QUICK, RESERVED, RET, RETURN, SALOAD, SAME_FRAME, SAME_FRAME_EXTENDED, SAME_FRAME_MAX, SAME_LOCALS_1_STACK_ITEM_FRAME, SAME_LOCALS_1_STACK_ITEM_FRAME_EXTENDED, SAME_LOCALS_1_STACK_ITEM_FRAME_MAX, SASTORE, SHORT_TYPE_NAMES, SIPUSH, STATIC_INITIALIZER_NAME, SWAP, SWITCH, T_ADDRESS, T_ARRAY, T_BOOLEAN, T_BYTE, T_CHAR, T_DOUBLE, T_FLOAT, T_INT, T_LONG, T_OBJECT, T_REFERENCE, T_SHORT, T_UNKNOWN, T_VOID, TABLESWITCH, TYPE_NAMES, TYPE_OF_OPERANDS, UNDEFINED, UNPREDICTABLE, WIDE

Constructor Summary

Constructors

Constructor and Description
SuspiciousComparatorReturnValues(edu.umd.cs.findbugs.BugReporter bugReporter) constructs a SCRV detector given the reporter to report bugs on

Method Summary

Modifier and Type	Method and Description
private void	processIntegerReturn() processes an IRETURN looking for constants and categorizes them as negative, zero or positive.
void	sawOpcode(int seen) implements the visitor to look for returns of constant values, and records them for being negative, zero or positive.
void	visitClassContext(edu.umd.cs.findbugs.ba.ClassContext classContext) implements the visitor to actually iterate twice over this class, once for compareTo and once for compare.
void	visitCode(org.apache.bcel.classfile.Code obj) implements the visitor to check to see what constants were returned from a comparator.

Methods inherited from class edu.umd.cs.findbugs.BytecodeScanningDetector

getClassContext, report, shouldVisitCode

Methods inherited from class edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.DismantleBytecode

afterOpcode, areOppositeBranches, atCatchBlock, beforeOpcode, getBranchFallThrough, getBranchOffset, getBranchTarget, getClassConstantOperand, getClassDescriptorOperand, getCodeByte, getConstantRefOperand, getDefaultSwitchOffset, getDottedClassConstantOperand, getFieldDescriptorOperand, getIntConstant, getLongConstant, getMaxPC, getMethodDescriptorOperand, getNameConstantOperand, getNextCodeByte, getNextOpcode, getNextPC, getOpcode, getPC, getPrevOpcode, getRefConstantOperand, getRefFieldIsStatic, getRegisterOperand, getSigConstantOperand, getStringConstantOperand, getSwitchLabels, getSwitchOffsets, getXClassOperand, getXFieldOperand, getXMethodOperand, isBranch, isMethodCall, isRegisterLoad, isRegisterStore, isRegisterStore, isReturn, isShift, isSwitch, isWideOpcode, printOpCode, sawBranchTo, sawClass, sawDouble, sawField, sawFloat, sawIMethod, sawInt, sawLong, sawMethod, sawRegister, sawString, visit

Methods inherited from class edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.AnnotationVisitor

getAnnotationParameterAsString, getAnnotationParameterAsStringArray, visitAnnotation, visitAnnotation, visitParameterAnnotation, visitParameterAnnotation, visitSyntheticParameterAnnotation

Methods inherited from class edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.PreorderVisitor

amVisitingMainMethod, asUnsignedByte, doVisitMethod, getClassDescriptor, getClassName, getCode, getConstantPool, getDottedClassName, getDottedFieldSig, getDottedMethodSig, getDottedSuperclassName, getField, getFieldDescriptor, getFieldIsStatic, getFieldName, getFieldSig, getFullyQualifiedFieldName, getFullyQualifiedMethodName, getMethod, getMethodDescriptor, getMethodName, getMethodSig, getMethodVisitOrder, getNumberArguments, getNumberMethodArguments, getPackageName, getSizeOfSurroundingTryBlock, getSizeOfSurroundingTryBlock, getSourceFile, getStringFromIndex, getSuperclassName, getSurroundingCaughtExceptions, getSurroundingCaughtExceptions, getSurroundingTryBlock, getSurroundingTryBlock, getThisClass, getXClass, getXField, getXMethod, hasInterestingClass, hasInterestingMethod, isVisitMethodsInCallOrder, setupVisitorForClass, setVisitMethodsInCallOrder, shouldVisit, toString, visitAfter, visitAfter, visitAnnotationDefault, visitAnnotationEntry, visitConstantPool, visitEnclosingMethod, visitingField, visitingMethod, visitInnerClasses, visitJavaClass, visitLineNumberTable, visitLocalVariableTable, visitStackMapTable, visitStackMapTableEntry

Methods inherited from class edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.BetterVisitor

clone, report, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visit, visitCodeException, visitConstantClass, visitConstantDouble, visitConstantFieldref, visitConstantFloat, visitConstantInteger, visitConstantInterfaceMethodref, visitConstantLong, visitConstantMethodref, visitConstantNameAndType, visitConstantString, visitConstantUtf8, visitConstantValue, visitDeprecated, visitExceptionTable, visitField, visitInnerClass, visitLineNumber, visitLocalVariable, visitLocalVariableTypeTable, visitMethod, visitSignature, visitSourceFile, visitStackMap, visitStackMapEntry, visitSynthetic, visitUnknown

Methods inherited from class java.lang.Object

equals, finalize, getClass, hashCode, notify, notifyAll, wait, wait, wait

Field Detail

compareClasses

private static java.util.List<CompareSpec> compareClasses

stack

private edu.umd.cs.findbugs.OpcodeStack stack

bugReporter

private final edu.umd.cs.findbugs.BugReporter bugReporter

methodInfo

private MethodInfo methodInfo

seenNegative

private boolean seenNegative

seenPositive

private boolean seenPositive

seenZero

private boolean seenZero

seenUnconditionalNonZero

private boolean seenUnconditionalNonZero

furthestBranchTarget

private int furthestBranchTarget

sawConstant

private java.lang.Integer sawConstant

Constructor Detail

SuspiciousComparatorReturnValues

public SuspiciousComparatorReturnValues(edu.umd.cs.findbugs.BugReporter bugReporter)

constructs a SCRV detector given the reporter to report bugs on

Parameters:

bugReporter - the sync of bug reports

Method Detail

visitClassContext

public void visitClassContext(edu.umd.cs.findbugs.ba.ClassContext classContext)

implements the visitor to actually iterate twice over this class, once for compareTo and once for compare.

Specified by:

visitClassContext in interface edu.umd.cs.findbugs.Detector

Overrides:

visitClassContext in class edu.umd.cs.findbugs.BytecodeScanningDetector

Parameters:

classContext - the currently parsed class

visitCode

public void visitCode(org.apache.bcel.classfile.Code obj)

implements the visitor to check to see what constants were returned from a comparator. If no constants were returned it can't determine anything, however if only constants were returned, it looks to see if negative positive and zero was returned. It also looks to see if a non zero value is returned unconditionally. While it is possible that later check is ok, it usually means something is wrong.

Specified by:

visitCode in interface org.apache.bcel.classfile.Visitor

Overrides:

visitCode in class edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.PreorderVisitor

Parameters:

obj - the currently parsed code block

sawOpcode

public void sawOpcode(int seen)

implements the visitor to look for returns of constant values, and records them for being negative, zero or positive. It also records unconditional returns of non zero values

Overrides:

sawOpcode in class edu.umd.cs.findbugs.visitclass.DismantleBytecode

Parameters:

seen - the currently parsed opcode

processIntegerReturn

private void processIntegerReturn()

processes an IRETURN looking for constants and categorizes them as negative, zero or positive. it also records a unconditional return of a non zero value Throws StopOpcodeParsingException if a return value (constant) is indeterminate